THE SKINNY: Yes, $25 is a lot to pay for an eyeliner. But Marc Jacobs Highliner Gel Crayon is worth the extra money.
I traded in some Sephora points to nab a sample in black, and it's by far the richest and prettiest black I have in my makeup drawer. This eyeliner goes on smooth and is easy to blend.
Topped with a little bit of shadow, it stayed in place all day, then rinsed clean with my usual face cleanser.
The black is vivid, a lot darker and richer than my usual Urban Decay and Smashbox blacks.
KEEP OR TOSS: Keep. It's gorgeous. Really.
CHECK IT OUT: Highliner Gel Crayon comes in six colors. I'd love to try N(ice), a light silver with shimmer.
-- Tested by Shay