THE SKINNY: This is a decent, everyday mascara that works just fine. I didn't get crazy volume from the mascara, but it did put a nice coat of black mascara on my lashes that lasted all day long. It didn't flake off or smudge, either.
The formula is a little thick, but it hasn't clumped up yet. The thickness does make it difficult to apply more than one coat if you're going for really dramatic lashes.
The brush is an average brush without a fancy shape or any bells and whistles that can sometime make applying the mascara difficult.
At the end of the day, Stila's product washed off much easier that I would expect from a waterproof mascara.
KEEP OR TOSS: Keep. I have no real complaints.
CHECK IT OUT: Stila offers a lot of special deals plus free samples on its website.
-- Tested by Shay