THE SKINNY: This is a soft, velvety waterproof shadow pencil that, true to its billing, doesn’t crease or clump. My color, pearly pink beige, lasted about seven hours before it faded away, still looking naturally. Even better, it didn’t make my eye lids feel sticky or heavy.
Unfortunately, the shadow pencil is rather soft and the tip broke the first time I used it, as I was finishing the second lid. So back it went to Sephora.
KEEP OR TOSS: If it didn’t break, I would have kept it. The color and the texture was to die for.
CHECK IT OUT: Sephora sells this product in a dozen shades, ranging from neutrals to brights.
-- Tested by Shay