THE SKINNY: Starlooks Kohl Eye Pencil is supposed to be an "intensely pigmented" pencil.
Maybe it's because my shade -- obsidian -- is a matte color, but this pencil is just ho-hum. It's not very intense at all.
It's fairly easy to apply and has a good "pencil" texture. It's not creamy and stays put after you apply it. The color lasts about half a day before it begins to wear off.
Given all that, $12 seems a little expensive for what you get.
KEEP OR TOSS: Keep, but it will probably find its way to the bottom of the eye product drawer.
CHECK IT OUT: Starlooks Kohl Eye Pencil comes in 11 shades. Some are satin and some are matte.
-- Tested by Shay