THE SKINNY: Butter London's WINK Eye Pencil is hands-down the best product I have tried in a long time. (And one of only ha handful that has earned 5 stars on this site.)
The smoky gray crayon-style eye liner glides on with ease. With primer it stays all day long. Despite any conditions. Even after sweating.
And it looks just applied up to 10 hours after application. What more could you want in a liner?
This liner comes in high colors and has a hint of shimmer. The pencil creates an almost perfect line every time without a sharpener. Plus, it is waterproof and will not smudge. (I dare you to try!)
I am using the smoky gray as a thick eye liner base with a neutral shadow these days and it makes a perfect day look.
KEEP OR TOSS: Keep.
CHECK IT OUT: The WINK eye pencil comes in 13 colors.
-- Tested by Carrie