THE SKINNY: I wouldn't call Pacifica's Natural Water-Proof Eye Pencil "waterproof." This creamy eyeliner (my sample from Ipsy was a standard brown called "fringe") rubbed off with one swipe of my finger. Even when I was careful, the color didn't stay put for more than an hour.
It would have been an OK everyday liner if it hadn't been touted as waterproof. But for $11 I expect a lot more.
KEEP OR TOSS: Toss. I love Pacifica's body lotions and scents. But so far the makeup line has been disappointing.
CHECK IT OUT: Pacifica Natural Water-Proof Eye Pencil comes in four colors: Black, brown, gray and nude.
-- Tested by Shay