COST: $24 for 4 ounces
THE SKINNY: Skinn's Olive & Enzyme Cleanser suffers from an identity crisis.
It's a makeup remover, a cleanser and a mask. And it doesn't do a great job with any of those tasks.
Billed as a "water-free, super-rich, night-time cleansing balm," this soap is thick and gooey. It dissolves if you mix it with water, so don't expect any bubbles or froth.
It goes on thick like a mask, but never really dries on your skin. When I rinsed it off, my skin felt a little oily and not very clean. It didn't do much to remove mascara.
Really, the only good thing about this soap is the scent, which smells like an Orange Creamsicle.
KEEP OR TOSS: Toss. I think this made my chin break out, too.
CHECK IT OUT: Find a full list of ingredients on the Skinn website.
-- Tested by Shay