THE SKINNY: When this came out of a recent Ipsy bag, it looked really clumpy on the brush and out of the tube. My heart sank.
This mascara, made with argan oil, may be a little messy, but it delivers dark, mostly clump-free, rich lashes with a lot of shine. The mascara lasts all day without flaking. My lashes actually look moisturized, too.
For waterproof mascara, it comes off fairly easily with a makeup with or makeup remover.
KEEP OR TOSS: Keep, but I'm not sure for how long.
CHECK IT OUT: Layer Pür Minerals Big Look Waterproof Mascara for a more dramatic look.
-- Tested by Shay