THE SKINNY: If you love Urban Decay's 24/7 Glide On Eye Pencils, you'll be happy with the latest incarnation: Velvet.
This is a matte black liner that goes on looking slightly smudged (but still stays in place all day). This pencil blends into a smokey eye makeup without a lot of work. My favorite part is it's easy to apply without worrying about the line being perfectly straight.
The color is pretty and warm, a nice contrast to the inky black of the regular Glide-On Eye Pencil. And it really does look velvety.
KEEP OR TOSS: Keep.
CHECK IT OUT: Find this pencil at Urban Decay's website. (While you're at it, the Black Market liner set is marked down in the sale section.)
-- Tested by Shay