THE SKINNY: A recent Ipsy makeup bag came with a full-size sample of mascara from Michelle Phan's new(ish) makeup line. It's a decent product.
Lash Gallery Dramatic Volume Mascara might look a little clumpy on the brush, but it doesn't leave any extra residue on my lashes. The color is rich and shiny and doesn't flake away throughout the day.
My only complaint is that this mascara has a noticeable odor, kind of a glue-like scent. It's not enough to make my eyes water, but I do notice it and find it a little odd.
KEEP OR TOSS: Keep. The brown is dark enough for my fair complexion.
CHECK IT OUT: Michelle Phan has several mascara formulas available.
-- Tested by Shay