COST: $12 (bought for $5 on a sale table in store)
THE SKINNY: This may be one of the best products I’ve ever found on a sale table at Sephora. This pot of cream eyeliner in a color called Cafe is a warm and golden brown that stays in place all day long. It’s been a few months, and the product is still creamy and glides onto my eyes.
Just dip an angled eyeliner brush into the pot of goodness and apply it as thin or as thick as you like. It blends easily for the first few minutes, then locks in place.
It comes off easily with face soap and water, too.
KEEP OR TOSS: Keep. It’s a great color that lasts.
CHECK IT OUT: Smoky Cream Liner comes in four colors.
-- Tested by Shay