RATING (out of 5 stars): 3.5 stars
THE SKINNY: I've seen the brand around for a while and always heard good things, but had never tried a Stila eyeshadow until recently and I was pretty impressed.
I used "Cloud," a beautiful shimmery neutral that words as a great below-the-brow accent shade. The shadow glided on smooth and had a nice sheen without making me look age-inappropriate.
The color held most of the day and it did not irritate my contacts one bit.
Shadows also come in cute little magnetic pots that are great for adding to any makeup case.
KEEP OR TOSS: Keep. The shadows are not too expensive and there are always deals on this brand out there.
CHECK IT OUT: Stila offers a custom makeup color finder on its site, which is pretty cool. Use it to select your perfect shade and order direct (with free shipping over $50). You can also find Stila shadows at Sephora.
-- Tested by Carrie